A number of moonshot solutions to cool the planet have gained traction in recent years amid faltering efforts to stem climate change by cutting emissions.

The shake-up is due to be completed by the time of the IMF and World Bank’s mid-October meetings.

The EU is currently trying to simplify its sustainable finance framework.

Ever since freezers were invented, the life sciences industry has been reliant on them. That’s because many patient samples, drug candidates, and other biologics must be stored and transported in powerful freezers or surrounded by dry ice to remain stable.

The problem was on full display during the Covid-19 pandemic, when truckloads of vaccines had to be discarded because they had thawed during transport. Today, the stakes are even higher. Precision medicine, from CAR-T cell therapies to tumor DNA sequencing that guides cancer treatment, depends on pristine biological samples. Yet a single power outage, shipping delay, or equipment failure can destroy irreplaceable patient samples, setting back treatment by weeks or halting it entirely. In remote areas and developing nations, the lack of reliable cold storage effectively locks out entire populations from these life-saving advances.

Cache DNA wants to set the industry free from freezers. At MIT, the company’s founders created a new way to store and preserve DNA molecules at room temperature. Now the company is building biomolecule preservation technologies that can be used in applications across health care, from routine blood tests and cancer screening to rare disease research and pandemic preparedness.

“We want to challenge the paradigm,” says Cache DNA co-founder and former MIT postdoc James Banal. “Biotech has been reliant on the cold chain for more than 50 years. Why hasn’t that changed? Meanwhile, the cost of DNA sequencing has plummeted from $3 billion for the first human genome to under $200 today. With DNA sequencing and synthesis becoming so cheap and fast, storage and transport have emerged as the critical bottlenecks. It’s like having a supercomputer that still requires punch cards for data input.”

As the company works to preserve biomolecules beyond DNA and scale the production of its kits, co-founders Banal and MIT Professor Mark Bathe believe their technology has the potential to unlock new health insights by making sample storage accessible to scientists around the world.

“Imagine if every human on Earth could contribute to a global biobank, not just those living near million-dollar freezer facilities,” Banal says. “That’s 8 billion biological stories instead of just a privileged few. The cures we’re missing might be hiding in the biomolecules of someone we’ve never been able to reach.”

From quantum computing to “Jurassic Park”

Banal came to MIT from Australia to work as a postdoc under Bathe, a professor in MIT’s Department of Biological Engineering. Banal primarily studied in the MIT-Harvard Center for Excitonics, through which he collaborated with researchers from across MIT.

“I worked on some really wacky stuff, like DNA nanotechnology and its intersection with quantum computing and artificial photosynthesis,” Banal recalls.

Another project focused on using DNA to store data. While computers store data as 0s and 1s, DNA can store the same information using the nucleotides A, T, G, and C, allowing for extremely dense storage of data: By one estimate, 1 gram of DNA can hold up to 215 petabytes of data.

After three years of work, in 2021, Banal and Bathe created a system that stored DNA-based data in tiny glass particles. They founded Cache DNA the same year, securing the intellectual property by working with MIT’s Technology Licensing Office, applying the technology to storing clinical nucleic acid samples as well as DNA data. Still, the technology was too nascent to be used for most commercial applications at the time.

Professor of chemistry Jeremiah Johnson had a different approach. His research had shown that certain plastics and rubbers could be made recyclable by adding cleavable molecular bonds. Johnson thought Cache DNA’s technology could be faster and more reliable using his amber-like polymers, similar to how researchers in the “Jurassic Park” movie recover ancient dinosaur DNA from a tree’s fossilized amber resin.

“It started basically as a fun conversation along the halls of Building 16,” Banal recalls. “He’d seen my work, and I was aware of the innovations in his lab.”

Banal immediately saw the potential. He was familiar with the burden of the cold chain. For his MIT experiments, he’d store samples in big freezers kept at -80 degrees Celsius. Samples would sometimes get lost in the freezer or be buried in the inevitable ice build-up. Even when they were perfectly preserved, samples could degrade as they thawed.

As part of a collaboration between Cache DNA and MIT, Banal, Johnson, and two researchers in Johnson’s lab developed a polymer that stores DNA at room temperature. In a nod to their inspiration, they demonstrated the approach by encoding DNA sequences with the “Jurassic Park” theme song.

The researchers’ polymers could encompass a material as a liquid and then form a solid, glass-like block when heated. To release the DNA, the researchers could add a molecule called cysteamine and a special detergent. The researchers showed the process could work to store and access all 50,000 base pairs of a human genome without causing damage.

“Real amber is not great at preservation. It’s porous and lets in moisture and air,” Banal says. “What we built is completely different: a dense polymer network that forms an impenetrable barrier around DNA. Think of it like vacuum-sealing, but at the molecular level. The polymer is so hydrophobic that water and enzymes that would normally destroy DNA simply can’t get through.”

As that research was taking shape, Cache DNA was learning that sample storage was a huge problem from hospitals and research labs. In places like Florida and Singapore, researchers said contending with the effects of humidity on samples was another constant headache. Other researchers across the globe wanted to know if the technology would help them collect samples outside of the lab.

“Hospitals told us they were running out of space,” Banal says. “They had to throw samples out, limit sample collection, and as a last-case scenario, they would use a decades-old storage technology that leads to degradation after a short period of time. It became a north star for us to solve those problems.”

A new tool for precision health

Last year, Cache DNA sent out more than 100 of its first alpha DNA preservation kits to researchers around the world.

“We didn’t tell researchers what to use it for, and our minds were blown by the use cases,” Banal says. “Some used it for collecting samples in the field where cold shipping wasn't feasible. Others evaluated for long term archival storage. The applications were different, but the problem was universal: They all needed reliable storage without the constraint of refrigeration.”

Cache DNA has developed an entire suite of preservation technologies that can be optimized for different storage scenarios. The company also recently received a grant from the National Science Foundation to expand its technology to preserve a broader swath of biomolecules, including RNA and proteins, which could yield new insights into health and disease.

“This important innovation helps eliminate the cold chain and has the potential to unlock millions of genetic samples globally for Cache DNA to empower personalized medicine,” Bathe says. “Eliminating the cold chain is half the equation. The other half is scaling from thousands to millions or even billions of nucleic acid samples. Together, this could enable the equivalent of a ‘Google Books’ for nucleic acids stored at room temperature, either for clinical samples in hospital settings and remote regions of the world, or alternatively to facilitate DNA data storage and retrieval at scale.”

“Freezers have dictated where science could happen,” Banal says. “Remove that constraint, and you start to crack open possibilities: island nations studying their unique genetics without samples dying in transit; every rare disease patient worldwide contributing to research, not just those near major hospitals; the 2 billion people without reliable electricity finally joining global health studies. Room-temperature storage isn’t the whole answer, but every cure starts with a sample that survived the journey.”

Researchers at the Antimicrobial Resistance (AMR) interdisciplinary research group of the Singapore-MIT Alliance for Research and Technology (SMART), MIT’s research enterprise in Singapore, have developed a powerful tool capable of scanning thousands of biological samples to detect transfer ribonucleic acid (tRNA) modifications — tiny chemical changes to RNA molecules that help control how cells grow, adapt to stress, and respond to diseases such as cancer and antibiotic‑resistant infections. This tool opens up new possibilities for science, health care, and industry — from accelerating disease research and enabling more precise diagnostics to guiding the development of more effective medical treatments for diseases such as cancer and antibiotic-resistant infections.

For this study, the SMART AMR team worked in collaboration with researchers at MIT, Nanyang Technological University in Singapore, the University of Florida, the University at Albany in New York, and Lodz University of Technology in Poland.

Addressing current limitations in RNA modification profiling

Cancer and infectious diseases are complicated health conditions in which cells are forced to function abnormally by mutations in their genetic material or by instructions from an invading microorganism. The SMART-led research team is among the world’s leaders in understanding how the epitranscriptome — the over 170 different chemical modifications of all forms of RNA — controls growth of normal cells and how cells respond to stressful changes in the environment, such as loss of nutrients or exposure to toxic chemicals. The researchers are also studying how this system is corrupted in cancer or exploited by viruses, bacteria, and parasites in infectious diseases.

Current molecular methods used to study the expansive epitranscriptome and all of the thousands of different types of modified RNA are often slow, labor-intensive, costly, and involve hazardous chemicals, which limits research capacity and speed.

To solve this problem, the SMART team developed a new tool that enables fast, automated profiling of tRNA modifications — molecular changes that regulate how cells survive, adapt to stress, and respond to disease. This capability allows scientists to map cell regulatory networks, discover novel enzymes, and link molecular patterns to disease mechanisms, paving the way for better drug discovery and development, and more accurate disease diagnostics. 

Unlocking the complexity of RNA modifications

SMART’s open-access research, recently published in Nucleic Acids Research and titled “tRNA modification profiling reveals epitranscriptome regulatory networks in Pseudomonas aeruginosa,” shows that the tool has already enabled the discovery of previously unknown RNA-modifying enzymes and the mapping of complex gene regulatory networks. These networks are crucial for cellular adaptation to stress and disease, providing important insights into how RNA modifications control bacterial survival mechanisms. 

Using robotic liquid handlers, researchers extracted tRNA from more than 5,700 genetically modified strains of Pseudomonas aeruginosa, a bacterium that causes infections such as pneumonia, urinary tract infections, bloodstream infections, and wound infections. Samples were enzymatically digested and analyzed by liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS), a technique that separates molecules based on their physical properties and identifies them with high precision and sensitivity. 

As part of the study, the process generated over 200,000 data points in a high-resolution approach that revealed new tRNA-modifying enzymes and simplified gene networks controlling how cells respond and adapt to stress. For example, the data revealed that the methylthiotransferase MiaB, one of the enzymes responsible for tRNA modification ms2i6A, was found to be sensitive to the availability of iron and sulfur and to metabolic changes when oxygen is low. Discoveries like this highlight how cells respond to environmental stresses, and could lead to future development of therapies or diagnostics.

SMART’s automated system was specially designed to profile tRNA modifications across thousands of samples rapidly and safely. Unlike traditional methods, this tool integrates robotics to automate sample preparation and analysis, eliminating the need for hazardous chemical handling and reducing costs. This advancement increases safety, throughput, and affordability, enabling routine large-scale use in research and clinical labs.

A faster and automated way to study RNA

As the first system capable of quantitative, system‑wide profiling of tRNA modifications at this scale, the tool provides a unique and comprehensive view of the epitranscriptome — the complete set of RNA chemical modifications within cells. This capability allows researchers to validate hypotheses about RNA modifications, uncover novel biology, and identify promising molecular targets for developing new therapies.

“This pioneering tool marks a transformative advance in decoding the complex language of RNA modifications that regulate cellular responses,” says Professor Peter Dedon, co-lead principal investigator at SMART AMR, professor of biological engineering at MIT, and corresponding author of the paper. “Leveraging AMR’s expertise in mass spectrometry and RNA epitranscriptomics, our research uncovers new methods to detect complex gene networks critical for understanding and treating cancer, as well as antibiotic-resistant infections. By enabling rapid, large-scale analysis, the tool accelerates both fundamental scientific discovery and the development of targeted diagnostics and therapies that will address urgent global health challenges.”

Accelerating research, industry, and health-care applications

This versatile tool has broad applications across scientific research, industry, and health care. It enables large-scale studies of gene regulation, RNA biology, and cellular responses to environmental and therapeutic challenges. The pharmaceutical and biotech industry can harness it for drug discovery and biomarker screening, efficiently evaluating how potential drugs affect RNA modifications and cellular behavior. This aids the development of targeted therapies and personalized medical treatments.

“This is the first tool that can rapidly and quantitatively profile RNA modifications across thousands of samples,” says Jingjing Sun, research scientist at SMART AMR and first author of the paper. “It has not only allowed us to discover new RNA-modifying enzymes and gene networks, but also opens the door to identifying biomarkers and therapeutic targets for diseases such as cancer and antibiotic-resistant infections. For the first time, large-scale epitranscriptomic analysis is practical and accessible.”

Looking ahead: advancing clinical and pharmaceutical applications

Moving forward, SMART AMR plans to expand the tool’s capabilities to analyze RNA modifications in human cells and tissues, moving beyond microbial models to deepen understanding of disease mechanisms in humans. Future efforts will focus on integrating the platform into clinical research to accelerate the discovery of biomarkers and therapeutic targets. The translation of the technology into an epitranscriptome-wide analysis tool that can be used in pharmaceutical and health-care settings will drive the development of more effective and personalized treatments.

The research conducted at SMART is supported by the National Research Foundation Singapore under its Campus for Research Excellence and Technological Enterprise program.

The Interior secretary indicated that 1 degree of climate change was an acceptable consequence of ramping up fossil fuels for data centers.

Connecticut Gov. Ned Lamont said he's "happy to open up the conversation to other sources of energy, including natural gas."

The administration cites whale protection in its anti-wind agenda. But that concern vanishes for fossil fuel projects in whale habitat.

Facing legal challenges, the department dissolved the group whose members wrote a report critical of mainstream climate science.

The warnings came as the agency works to revoke the 2009 scientific finding that climate change threatens people.

Kip Lipper is at the center of state lawmakers’ gridlock on energy bills.

Geopolitical instability is forcing Europe to look to the heavens for its energy security.

Officials proposed setting up the hub as early as 2022, with firefighting aircraft that could quickly respond to wildfires in the Middle East.

Several apps help people figure out which actions create the most emissions and how to avoid them. An AP reporter tried three of them.

At MIT, a few scribbles on a whiteboard can turn into a potentially transformational cancer treatment.

This scenario came to fruition this week when the U.S. Food and Drug Administration approved a system for treating an aggressive form of bladder cancer. More than a decade ago, the system started as an idea in the lab of MIT Professor Michael Cima at the Koch Institute for Integrative Cancer Research, enabled by funding from the National Institutes of Health and MIT’s Deshpande Center.

The work that started with a few researchers at MIT turned into a startup, TARIS Biomedical LLC, that was co-founded by Cima and David H. Koch Institute Professor Robert Langer, and acquired by Johnson & Johnson in 2019. In developing the core concept of a device for local drug delivery to the bladder — which represents a new paradigm in bladder cancer treatment — the MIT team approached drug delivery like an engineering problem.

“We spoke to urologists and sketched out the problems with past treatments to get to a set of design parameters,” says Cima, a David H. Koch Professor of Engineering and professor of materials science and engineering. “Part of our criteria was it had to fit into urologists’ existing procedures. We wanted urologists to know what to do with the system without even reading the instructions for use. That’s pretty much how it came out.”

To date, the system has been used in patients thousands of times. In one study involving people with high-risk, non-muscle-invasive bladder cancer whose disease had proven resistant to standard care, doctors could find no evidence of cancer in 82.4 percent of patients treated with the system. More than 50 percent of those patients were still cancer-free nine months after treatment.

The results are extremely gratifying for the team of researchers that worked on it at MIT, including Langer and Heejin Lee SM ’04, PhD ’09, who developed the system as part of his PhD thesis. And Cima says far more people deserve credit than just the ones who scribbled on his whiteboard all those years ago.

“Drug products like this take an enormous amount of effort,” says Cima. “There are probably more than 1,000 people that have been involved in developing and commercializing the system: the MIT inventors, the urologists they consulted, the scientists at TARIS, the scientists at Johnson & Johnson — and that’s not including all the patients who participated in clinical trials. I also want to emphasize the importance of the MIT ecosystem, and the importance of giving people the resources to pursue arguably crazy ideas. We need to continue to support those kinds of activities.”

In the mid 2000s, Langer connected Cima with a urologist at Boston Children’s Hospital who was seeking a new treatment for a painful bladder disease known as interstitial cystitis. The standard treatment required frequent drug infusions into a patient’s bladder through a catheter, which provided only temporary relief.

A group of researchers including Cima; Lee; Hong Linh Ho Duc SM ’05, PhD ’09; Grace Kim PhD ’08; and Karen Daniel PhD ’09 began speaking with urologists and people who had run failed clinical trials involving bladder treatments to understand what went wrong. All that information went on Cima’s whiteboard over the course of several weeks. Fortunately, Cima also scribbled “Do not erase!”

“We learned a lot in the process of writing everything down,” Cima says. “We learned what not to build and what to avoid.”

With the problem well-defined, Cima received a grant from MIT’s Deshpande Center for Technological Innovation, which allowed Lee to work on designing a better solution as part of his PhD thesis.

One of the key advances the group made was using a special alloy that gave the device “shape memory” so that it could be straightened out and inserted into the bladder through a catheter. Then it would fold up, preventing it from being expelled during urination.

The new design was able to slowly release drugs over a two-week period — far longer than any other approach — and could then be removed using a thin, flexible tube commonly used in urology, called a cystoscope. The progress was enough for Cima and Langer, who are both serial entrepreneurs, to found TARIS Biomedical and license the technology from MIT. Lee and three other MIT graduates joined the company.

“It was a real pleasure working with Mike Cima, our students, and colleagues on this novel drug delivery system, which is already changing patients’ lives,” Langer says, “It’s a great example of how research at the Koch Institute starts with basic science and engineering and ends up with new treatments for cancer patients.”

The FDA’s approval of the system for the treatment of certain patients with high-risk, non-muscle-invasive bladder cancer now means that patients with this disease may have a better treatment option. Moving forward, Cima hopes the system continues to be explored to treat other diseases.

Everyone gets headaches. But not everyone gets cluster headache attacks, a debilitating malady producing acute pain that lasts an hour or two. Cluster headache attacks come in sets — hence the name — and leave people in complete agony, unable to function. A little under 1 percent of the U.S. population suffers from cluster headache.

But that’s just an outline of the matter. What’s it like to actually have a cluster headache?

“The pain of a cluster headache is such that you can’t sit still,” says MIT-based science journalist Tom Zeller, who has suffered from them for decades. “I’d liken it to putting your hand on a hot burner, except that you can’t take your hand off for an hour or two. Every headache is an emergency. You have to run or pace or rock. Think of another pain you had to dance through, but it just doesn’t stop. It’s that level of intensity, and it’s all happening inside your head.”

And then there is the pain of the migraine headache, which seems slightly less acute than a cluster attack, but longer-lasting, and similarly debilitating. Migraine attacks can be accompanied by extreme sensitivity to light and noise, vision issues, and nausea, among other neurological symptoms, leaving patients alone in dark rooms for hours or days. An estimated 1.2 billion people around the world, including 40 million in the U.S., struggle with migraine attacks.

These are not obscure problems. And yet: We don’t know exactly why migraine and cluster headache disorders occur, nor how to address them. Headaches have never been a prominent topic within modern medical research. How can something so pervasive be so overlooked?

Now Zeller examines these issues in an absorbing book, “The Headache: The Science of a Most Confounding Affliction — and a Search for Relief,” published this summer by Mariner Books. Zeller is the editor-in-chief and co-founder of Undark, a digital magazine on science and society published by the Knight Science Journalism Program at MIT.

One word, but different syndromes

“The Headache,” which is Zeller’s first book, combines a first-person narrative of his own suffering, accounts of the pain and dread that other headache sufferers feel, and thorough reporting on headache-based research in science and medicine. Zeller has experienced cluster headache attacks for 30-plus years, dating to when he was in his 20s.

“In some ways, I suppose I had been writing the book my whole adult life without knowing it,” Zeller says. Indeed, he had collected research material about these conditions for years while grappling with his own headache issues.

A key issue in the book is why society has not taken cluster headache and migraine problems more seriously — and relatedly, why the science of headache disorders is not more advanced. Although in fairness, as Zeller says, “Anything involving the brain or central nervous system is incredibly hard to study.”

More broadly, Zeller suggests in the book, we have conflated regular workaday headaches — the kind you may get from staring at a screen too long — with the far more severe and rather different disorders like cluster headache and migraine. (Some patients refer to cluster headache and migraine in the singular, not plural, to emphasize that this is an ongoing condition, not just successive headaches.)

“Headaches are annoying, and we tough it out,” Zeller says. “But we use the same exact word to talk about these other things,” namely, cluster headache and migraine. This has likely reinforced our general dismissal of severe headache disorders as a pressing and distinct medical problem. Instead, we often consider headache disorders, even severe ones, as something people should simply power through.

“There’s a certain sense of malingering we still attach to a migraine or [other] headache disorder, and I’m not sure that’s going away,” Zeller says.

Then too, about three-quarters of people who experience migraine attacks are women, which has quite plausibly led the ailment to “get short shrift historically,” as Zeller says. Or at least, in recent history: As Zeller chronicles in the book, an awareness of severe headache disorders goes back to ancient times, and it’s possible they have received less relative attention in modernity.

A new shift in medical thinking

In any case, for much of the 20th century, conventional medical wisdom held that migraine and cluster headache stemmed from changes or abnormalities in blood vessels. But in recent decades, as Zeller details, there has been a paradigm shift: These conditions are now seen as more neurological in origin.

A key breakthrough here was the 1980s discovery of a neurotransmitter called calcitonin gene-related peptide, or CGRP. As scientists have discovered, CGRP is released from nerve endings around blood vessels and helps produce migraine symptoms. This offered a new strategy — and target — for combating severe head pain. The first drugs to inhibit the effects of CGRP hit the market in 2018, and most researchers in the field are now focused on idiopathic headache as a neurological disorder, not a vascular problem.

“It’s the way science works,” Zeller says. “Changing course is not easy. It’s like turning a ship on a dime. The same applies to the study of headaches.”

Many medications aimed at blocking these neurotransmitters have since been developed, though only about 20 percent of patients seem to find permanent relief as a result. As Zeller chronicles, other patients feel benefits for about a year, before the effects of a medication wear off; many of them now try complicated combinations of medications.

Severe headache disorders also seem linked to hormonal changes in people, who often see an onset of these ailments in their teens, and a diminishing of symptoms later in life. So, while headache medicine has witnessed a recent breakthrough, much more work lies ahead.

Opening up a discussion

Amid all this, one set of questions still tugging at Zeller is evolutionary in nature: Why do humans experience headache disorders at all? There is no clear evidence that other species get severe headaches — or that the prevalence of severe headache conditions in society has ever diminished.

One hypothesis, Zeller notes, is that “having a highly attuned nervous system could have been a benefit in our more primitive state.” Such a system may have helped us survive, in the past, but at the cost of producing intense disorders in some people when the wiring goes a bit awry. We may learn more about this as neuro-based headache research continues.

“The Headache” has received widespread praise. Writing in The New Yorker, Jerome Groopman heralded the “rich material in the book,” noting that it “weaves together history, biology, a survey of current research, testimony from patients, and an agonizing account of Zeller’s own suffering.”

For his part, Zeller says he is appreciative of the attention “The Headache” has generated, as one of the most widely-noted nonfiction books released this summer.

“It’s opened up room for a kind of conversation that doesn’t usually break through into the mainstream,” Zeller says. “I’m hearing from a lot of patients who just are saying, ‘Thank you for writing this.’ And that’s really gratifying. I’m most happy to hear from people who think it’s giving them a voice. I’m also hearing a lot from doctors and scientists. The moment has opened up for this discussion, and I’m grateful for that.”

Nature Climate Change, Published online: 11 September 2025; doi:10.1038/s41558-025-02434-7

The role of climate science is changing — fast. Once positioned to inform policy, scientific assessments are increasingly being used in courtrooms to substantiate claims of harm, causation and state responsibility. Climate knowledge has now become legal evidence in the fight for climate justice.

Nature Climate Change, Published online: 11 September 2025; doi:10.1038/s41558-025-02428-5

How evapotranspiration changes with warming is not well understood. Here the authors show that when often-neglected land–atmosphere feedbacks are considered, evapotranspiration increases less than currently projected by offline models.

If the Supreme Court doesn’t reverse a lower court’s ruling, internet service providers (ISPs) could be forced to terminate people’s internet access based on nothing more than mere accusations of copyright infringement. This would threaten innocent users who rely on broadband for essential aspects of daily life. EFF—along with the American Library Association, the Association of Research Libraries, and Re:Create—filed an amicus brief urging the Court to reverse the decision.

The Stakes: Turning ISPs into Copyright Police

Among other things, the Supreme Court approving the appeals court’s findings will radically change the amount of risk your ISP takes on if a customer infringes on copyright, forcing the ISP to terminate access to the internet for those users accused of copyright infringement—and everyone else who uses that internet connection.

This issue turns on what courts call “secondary liability,” which is the legal idea that someone can be held responsible not for what they did directly, but for what someone else did using their product or service.

The case began when music companies sued Cox Communications, arguing that the ISP should be held liable for copyright infringement committed by some of its subscribers. The Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit agreed, adopting a “material contribution” standard for contributory copyright liability (a rule for when service providers can be held liable for the actions of users). The lower court said that providing a service that could be used for infringement is enough to create liability when a customer infringes.

In the Patent Act, where Congress has explicitly defined secondary liability, there’s a different test: contributory infringement exists only where a product is incapable of substantial non-infringing use. Internet access, of course, is overwhelmingly used for lawful purposes, making it the very definition of a “staple article of commerce” that can’t be liable under the patent framework. Yet under the Fourth Circuit’s rule, ISPs could face billion-dollar damages if they fail to terminate users on the basis of even flimsy or automated infringement claims.

Our Argument: Apply Clear Rules from the Patent Act, Not Confusing Judge-Made Tests

Our brief urges the Court to do what it has done in the past: look to patent law to define the limits of secondary liability in copyright. That means contributory infringement must require more than a “material contribution” by the service provider—it should apply only when a product or service is especially designed for infringement and lacks substantial non-infringing uses.

The Human Cost: Losing Internet Access Hurts Everyone

The Fourth Circuit’s rule threatens devastating consequences for the public. Terminating an ISP account doesn’t just affect a person accused of unauthorized file sharing—it cuts off entire households, schools, libraries, or businesses that share an internet connection.

• Public libraries, which provide internet access to millions of Americans who lack it at home, could lose essential service.
• Universities, hospitals, and local governments could see internet access for whole communities disrupted.
• Households—especially in low-income and communities of color, which disproportionately share broadband connections with other people—would face collective punishment for the alleged actions of a single user.

With more than a third of Americans having only one or no broadband provider, many users would have no way to reconnect once cut off. And given how essential internet access is for education, employment, healthcare, and civic participation, the consequences of termination are severe and disproportionate.

What’s Next

The Supreme Court has an opportunity to correct course. We’re asking the Court to reject the Fourth Circuit’s unfounded “material contribution” test, reaffirm that patent law provides the right framework for secondary liability, and make clear that the Constitution requires copyright to serve the public good. The Court should ensure that copyright enforcement doesn’t jeopardize the internet access on which participation in modern life depends.

We’ll be watching closely as the Court considers this case. In the meantime, you can read our amicus brief here.

Whether you’re an artist, advertising specialist, or just looking to spruce up your home, turning everyday objects into dynamic displays is a great way to make them more visually engaging. For example, you could turn a kids’ book into a handheld cartoon of sorts, making the reading experience more immersive and memorable for a child.

But now, thanks to MIT researchers, it’s also possible to make dynamic displays without using electronics, using barrier-grid animations (or scanimations), which use printed materials instead. This visual trick involves sliding a patterned sheet across an image to create the illusion of a moving image. The secret of barrier-grid animations lies in its name: An overlay called a barrier (or grid) often resembling a picket fence moves across, rotates around, or tilts toward an image to reveal frames in an animated sequence. That underlying picture is a combination of each still, sliced and interwoven to present a different snapshot depending on the overlay’s position.

While tools exist to help artists create barrier-grid animations, they’re typically used to create barrier patterns that have straight lines. Building off of previous work in creating images that appear to move, researchers at MIT’s Computer Science and Artificial Intelligence Laboratory (CSAIL) have developed a tool that allows users to explore more unconventional designs. From zigzags to circular patterns, the team’s “FabObscura” software turns unique concepts into printable scanimations, helping users add dynamic animations to things like pictures, toys, and decor.

MIT Department of Electrical Engineering and Computer Science (EECS) PhD student and CSAIL researcher Ticha Sethapakdi SM ’19, a lead author on a paper presenting FabObscura, says that the system is a one-size-fits-all tool for customizing barrier-grid animations. This versatility extends to unconventional, elaborate overlay designs, like pointed, angled lines to animate a picture you might put on your desk, or the swirling, hypnotic appearance of a radial pattern you could spin over an image placed on a coin or a Frisbee.

“Our system can turn a seemingly static, abstract image into an attention-catching animation,” says Sethapakdi. “The tool lowers the barrier to entry to creating these barrier-grid animations, while helping users express a variety of designs that would’ve been very time-consuming to explore by hand.”

Behind these novel scanimations is a key finding: Barrier patterns can be expressed as any continuous mathematical function — not just straight lines. Users can type these equations into a text box within the FabObscura program, and then see how it graphs out the shape and movement of a barrier pattern. If you wanted a traditional horizontal pattern, you’d enter in a constant function, where the output is the same no matter the input, much like drawing a straight line across a graph. For a wavy design, you’d use a sine function, which is smooth and resembles a mountain range when plotted out. The system’s interface includes helpful examples of these equations to guide users toward their preferred pattern.

A simple interface for elaborate ideas

FabObscura works for all known types of barrier-grid animations, supporting a variety of user interactions. The system enables the creation of a display with an appearance that changes depending on your viewpoint. FabObscura also allows you to create displays that you can animate by sliding or rotating a barrier over an image.

To produce these designs, users can upload a folder of frames of an animation (perhaps a few stills of a horse running), or choose from a few preset sequences (like an eye blinking) and specify the angle your barrier will move. After previewing your design, you can fabricate the barrier and picture onto separate transparent sheets (or print the image on paper) using a standard 2D printer, such as an inkjet. Your image can then be placed and secured on flat, handheld items such as picture frames, phones, and books.

You can enter separate equations if you want two sequences on one surface, which the researchers call “nested animations.” Depending on how you move the barrier, you’ll see a different story being told. For example, CSAIL researchers created a car that rotates when you move its sheet vertically, but transforms into a spinning motorcycle when you slide the grid horizontally.

These customizations lead to unique household items, too. The researchers designed an interactive coaster that you can switch from displaying a “coffee” icon to symbols of a martini and a glass of water by pressing your fingers down on the edges of its surface. The team also spruced up a jar of sunflower seeds, producing a flower animation on the lid that blooms when twisted off.

Artists, including graphic designers and printmakers, could also use this tool to make dynamic pieces without needing to connect any wires. The tool saves them crucial time to explore creative, low-power designs, such as a clock with a mouse that runs along as it ticks. FabObscura could produce animated food packaging, or even reconfigurable signage for places like construction sites or stores that notify people when a particular area is closed or a machine isn’t working.

Keep it crisp

FabObscura’s barrier-grid creations do come with certain trade-offs. While nested animations are novel and more dynamic than a single-layer scanimation, their visual quality isn’t as strong. The researchers wrote design guidelines to address these challenges, recommending users upload fewer frames for nested animations to keep the interlaced image simple and stick to high-contrast images for a crisper presentation.

In the future, the researchers intend to expand what users can upload to FabObscura, like being able to drop in a video file that the program can then select the best frames from. This would lead to even more expressive barrier-grid animations.

FabObscura might also step into a new dimension: 3D. While the system is currently optimized for flat, handheld surfaces, CSAIL researchers are considering implementing their work into larger, more complex objects, possibly using 3D printers to fabricate even more elaborate illusions.

Sethapakdi wrote the paper with several CSAIL affiliates: Zhejiang University PhD student and visiting researcher Mingming Li; MIT EECS PhD student Maxine Perroni-Scharf; MIT postdoc Jiaji Li; MIT associate professors Arvind Satyanarayan and Justin Solomon; and senior author and MIT Associate Professor Stefanie Mueller, leader of the Human-Computer Interaction (HCI) Engineering Group at CSAIL. Their work will be presented at the ACM Symposium on User Interface Software and Technology (UIST) this month.